Communicating with unconscious patients is easy, if you overlook the ethics

Cosmos Magazine

Cosmos

Cosmos is a quarterly science magazine. We aim to inspire curiosity in ‘The Science of Everything’ and make the world of science accessible to everyone.

By Cosmos

The science proves we can communicate with unconscious or “locked-in” patients, but should we? asks Steven Laureys at Cosmos Weekly.

Brain-machine interfaces can decipher thoughts and help give some unconscious patients – often referred to as “locked-in” coma survivors – a voice. But first we must ensure they’re responsive.

Consciousness is not binary; it’s gradual, with many dimensions. While that might seem like a consideration to be pondered by philosophers, it can have major real-world implications.

In 2009, a 21-year-old woman was assessed by my team at the University Hospital of Liège in Belgium. She was considered comatose on arrival. But a recording of her brain’s electrical activity showed she could respond to her name in a list of random names. Her brain activity responded to simple questions — she was hearing, understanding and doing what she was asked to do. In other cases, she would have been deemed comatose or vegetative but her brain showed she was conscious, yet suffering from a total locked-in syndrome with no means of speaking or moving. The moment was significant as clinicians were discussing end-of-life decisions with her family at the time. She subsequently recovered and was eventually able to control a wheelchair.

There has been a historical misconception that consciousness is either ‘all or nothing’ — that comatose or vegetative patients are completely unaware. Clinicians sometimes fail to recognise minimal signs of consciousness after a coma. And often it’s the family who first realises there’s more going on in the brain of a patient. Consciousness is possible, despite not visibly appearing to be. Patients who exist in the shades of consciousness receive little attention — a literally silent epidemic.

“Often it’s the family who first realises there’s more going on in the brain of a patient.”


To read the rest of this article and discover others available only to members, click here for a free trial of Cosmos Weekly – your source for the science behind the economics, politics, and business news of the day, with expert commentary and analysis.

Please login to favourite this article.