8 December 2011

Social rats trade chocolate for cagemates

Rats will choose to liberate a trapped companion even when offered a reward of chocolate as an alternative, report researchers.
social rats

The presence of a rat trapped in a restrainer elicits focused activity from his cagemate, leading eventually to door-opening and consequent liberation of the trapped rat.
Credit: Science/AAAS

LONDON: Rats will choose to liberate a trapped companion even when offered a reward of chocolate as an alternative, report researchers.

A new study, published in Science today, demonstrates that rats are capable of ‘pro-social’ or voluntary helping behaviour motivated purely by the distress of their fellow rats. This type of behaviour has not previously been observed in rodents.

“Our results indicate that pro-social behaviour is much older evolutionarily than previously thought, extending beyond primates to rodents,” said study author Inbal Ben-Ami Bartal from the University of Chicago in the U.S.

“It is widely agreed today that the roots of empathy lie in the mother-offspring bond. Mothers need to be responsive to the needs of the offspring to ensure its survival, and this ability is also important in social groups, where the group’s survival is promoted by helping between individuals. As rats are very social animals it’s not surprising that they demonstrate this ability,” she added.

Social rats feel pain

Mice and rats are known to show ‘emotional contagion’ towards their fellows, in that they can detect and mimic each others emotional state, but actively helping other rodents requires an extra empathic step.

“We wanted to see if rats would go beyond emotional contagion to actively help another rat in distress,” said co-author Peggy Mason, also from the University of Chicago.

“This is really asking quite a bit of a rat as active helping requires that the helper rat do more than freeze in fear and distress. The helper rat has to down-regulate the fear experienced through emotional contagion. In other words, the helper has to suppress the natural response of frozen immobility and actually move and act to help the other rat.”

To test whether rats could display pro-social behaviour, the team placed a free laboratory rat in an enclosed area with a cagemate trapped in a plastic restrainer.
The free rats became agitated in the presence of a trapped companion, and after several sessions of trial and error learned how to open the restrainer doors to free the trapped rats.

Empathic motivation

To test the motivation of the rats in opening the restrainers, the investigators carried out the same experiment with empty restrainers and those containing objects such as a toy rat. However, the free rats did not open the restrainers in either of these scenarios.

The rats even learned how to open the restrainer in the absence of a food reward or external training. They also opened the restrainers even when they were prevented from socialising with the trapped rat afterwards, ruling out social interaction as a possible motivation. Rather, “they learned how to open the restrainer because they were internally motivated to liberate the trapped rat,” said Bartal.

Passing up chocolate chips

In an additional experiment, designed to test how valuable liberation of the trapped cagemate was to the free rat, the researchers placed a free rat in an area with a trapped rat and a food reward of chocolate chips in another closed restrainer.

Instead of opening the food containing restrainer and eating all the food themselves, the free rats not only freed the trapped rat, but in most instances also shared the chocolate with them. “Truly amazing from a rat perspective,” remarked Mason. “Imagine a rat seeing food and not eating it!”

“What’s nice about this is that this is pretty obvious pro-social behaviour and there is really no two ways about it,” said Jeffrey Mogil from McGill University in Montreal in Canada, an expert on rodent empathic behaviour. “It’s more than has been shown before by a long shot, and that’s very impressive, especially since there’s no advanced technology here.”

Confidence is everything

Although most of the free rats did learn to open the restrainer after some trial and error, a small percentage (around 25%) did not. The authors say that this could either be because they were less motivated to help their cagemates or because they were less effective helpers.

“Our findings indicate the latter as the most likely probability,” said Bartal. “We found that rats who were non-openers were also less bold than openers in a boldness test conducted before the experiment.”

“I think this is reasonable if you think about it in humans too,” suggested Mogil, “when they offer aid if they have too much stress themselves then they become paralysed and aren’t in a position to perform pro-social behaviours and so in some sense these data are perfectly aligned with human expectations as well.”

The investigators also noted that more ‘door openers’ were female than male consistent with previous suggestions that females may be more empathic than males.

The dangers of anthropomorphism

Mogil commented that one of the remarkable things about this experiment was the lack of advanced technology used to carry it out. He suggested that the reason it has taken scientists so long to carry out such a study may be because they have been “scared off from this sort of thing for a long time by worry that they were going to be charged with anthropomorphism.”

He added, “I think you are going to see a lot of this sort of thing about to happen because the threat of that charge has been diffused now, which is a good thing.”

Commenting on their research Bartal said, “We have created a model for empathic pro-social behaviour in rodents that is easy to replicate and can be used for a variety of research questions.” She added that it, “opens the path for elucidating aspects of the underlying neurophysiological mechanisms that were not accessible until now.”


Sign up to our free newsletter and have "This Week in Cosmos" delivered to your inbox every Monday.

>> More information
Like us on Facebook
Follow @CosmosMagazine
Add Cosmos to your Google+ circles

Get a weekly dose of Cosmos delivered straight to your inbox!

  • The latest in science each week
  • All the updates on our new website launch
  • Exclusive offers and competitions

Enter your name and email address below: