10 October 2008

Cacophony of ocean noise killing whales

Agence France-Presse
Underwater cacophony caused by commercial and military ships has become so intense that it is killing whales, according to scientists at the World Conservation Congress in Barcelona, Spain.
Dead whale

Noise pollution disorientates or physically damages whales leading to collisions, strandings and beachings. Credit: iStockphoto

BARCELONA: Underwater cacophony caused by commercial and military ships has become so intense that it is killing whales, according to scientists at the World Conservation Congress in Barcelona, Spain.

Sounds ranging from the hum of yacht motors to sonar blasts strong enough to destroy a whale’s inner ear are wreaking havoc on the ability of these cetaceans to migrate, feed and breed, they said on Thursday as a historic case began to be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Acoustic smog

“The noises generated by ships create what I call acoustic smog,” said Michel Andre, director of the Laboratory of Applied Bio-Acoustics in Barcelona.

Just as air pollution reduces one’s field of vision, “noise pollution in the sea reduces the zone in which whales can feed and hampers their ability to communicate,” he said. “There is no place in the world’s oceans that is untouched.”

Many shipping lanes follow the coastal routes that whales have traced for millions of years as they roam the planet’s seas. The result is a crescendo of beachings, strandings and collisions as whales and other sea mammals become disoriented or physically damaged by the noise and lose their bearings.

Weighty consequences

Recent research on a population of some 300 sperm whales living around the Canary Islands provides a unique window onto the problem.

Sperm whales normally migrate, but the squid upon which they feast are so plentiful in these waters that this group has made the region their permanent home, Andre said. Maritime traffic, however, is taking a terrible toll – since researchers began monitoring the area, 6 to 10 whales have been killed each year by collisions with ships.

“If we don’t do something, in a few years there won’t be any sperm whales left here,” Andre said. The consequences would extend beyond the loss of a whale population, he warned. “Each whale eats about one tonne of squid per day. All that uneaten squid would completely disrupt the food chain,” he said.

Some forms of noise pollution are so powerful that “a whale can be killed outright by the shock,” said Carl Gustav Landin, head of marine programmes for the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

Sonars used by the military and the oil industry can exceed 230 decibels in volume, and can be deadly within a one- or two-kilometre radius, Andre said. Eighty-five decibels – the unit used to measure sound pressure – can cause permanent damage to the human ear.

Research published in the United States last week shows that climate change is amplifying the problem.

The acidification of oceans caused by rising sea temperatures reduces sound absorption in the water by up to 40 per cent, meaning that noise travels much further. “Ambient noise levels in the ocean … are set to increase significantly,” the study, published in the Geophysical Research Letters, concluded.

A website created by Andre’s team demonstrates the scope and volume of the problem. The site features an interactive map showing the heavy maritime traffic around the Iberian peninsula, as well as the auditory footprint of each vessel in red.

By moving an icon representing a whale, one can hear the extent to which the sound the animal produces is masked by noise pollution. Working in partnership with other researchers around the world, Andre will soon extend the map to cover the world.

National security?

The plight of the whales has also recently come before the U.S. Supreme Court.

On Thursday, some of the judges indicated they favoured slapping down a lower court ruling that curbs the use of powerful sonar in U.S. Navy training exercises. Even if the sonar harms the giant sea mammals, national security would likely take priority, some of the justices suggested.

Claudia McMurray, assistant secretary of state for oceans, environment and science and head of the U.S. delegation at the congress in Barcelona, acknowledged it was hard to reconcile security and environmental interests. “It is a delicate balance for us,” she said.

But Andre insisted solutions are available. “Technology exists that would allow military to continue their activities without putting the future of whales in peril,” he said. “It is a shame this is not happening.”


Sign up to our free newsletter and have "This Week in Cosmos" delivered to your inbox every Monday.

>> More information
Like us on Facebook
Follow @CosmosMagazine
Add Cosmos to your Google+ circles

Get a weekly dose of Cosmos delivered straight to your inbox!

  • The latest in science each week
  • All the updates on our new website launch
  • Exclusive offers and competitions

Enter your name and email address below: